Card image

Complimentary Traffic Ticket Case Evaluations. Call Now. (315) 396-8006

Traffic Ticket Articles

DWI Chemical Test Refusal Hearings in New York

by Seth Azria on 8/03/2015

Having a Hearing Can be Valuable Even When Lost

I have had clients, and some attorneys, who ask me, “Should I go forward with a refusal hearing?”—and despite the fact that they are unlikely to win, I tell them that I believe that they should in most cases. Participating in a refusal hearing is an excellent way to get free discovery and to cross-examine the police officer about the underlying conduct in the case—both in terms of how your client was interacting with the officer and the officer’s observations of your client.

As a result, I tell my clients that they should never waive their right to a refusal hearing. In fact, the only time I suggest to clients that they should waive their right to that hearing is if the DA is willing to give them a resolution to the charges within a relatively short time frame. The reason for this is that if the driver loses the refusal hearing, driving privileges will be lost for one year. The only way to be able to drive during this one-year suspension period is to be eligible for a Conditional License, which allows a driver with a suspended license to drive to and from work and school. To be eligible for a Conditional License the driver must be eligible to attend the NYS Drinking Driver Program; and have been convicted of an alcohol related charge.

This means the driver cannot have taken, nor have been eligible to take and refused, the DDP program in the previous five years and that they must be convicted of an alcohol related offense. As long as a driver is eligible to participate in the NYS Drinking and Driving program they will at least be able to drive to and from school or work, even if they failed to take a breath test, and by statute, their license privileges have been suspended for one year.

The obvious import of this is if a driver is found to have refused a validly requested chemical test, they can only have driving privileges after they have been convicted of an alcohol related offense. The driver who loses his license for one year for a refusal, who is then successful at avoiding an alcohol related conviction, will have no ability to drive at all during the one year revocation. A dubious victory for the driver.

Article adapted from partner David C. Bruffett's chapter in "Inside the Minds: Strategies for Defending DWI Cases in New York, 2015 ed. published by Aspatore Books, A Thomson Reuters business. 

Need help with your ticket?

One speeding conviction may cause premiums to increase over $2,000 in three years. The Zebra. 

Don't plead guilty. .

Our experienced traffic defense lawyer is available to talk to you about your case.

Accepting Cases in Onondaga County Only.

Free Consultations. Call Now.
(315) 364-1155




 

Can't talk now?

Schedule a time for a lawyer to call you when it's convenient.

 Schedule a Call for Later

Azria & Bruffett PLLC BBB Business Review

Top Rated Award Winning Law Firm in Syracuse


Top Rated Award Winning Law Firm in Syracuse


Top Rated Law Firm, Syracuse NY

 
Hire your traffic lawyer online. Start Now
Google+ Review

Azria & Bruffett was a huge help in successfully defending me against a speeding violation in Great Valley NY. I am from out of state and would have had great difficulty defending myself. They knew the process, took care of everything for me, and kept me informed along the way. I highly recommend them.

Google+ Review

Pleased with the outcome. The firm is well worth their (very reasonable) fees.

Very pleased

I hired Seth to take care of a speeding ticket. He got it reduced to a no point ticket. The whole process was very simple and done through email. He took the time to answer any questions I had and his office kept me informed during the process.

A Speeding Ticket Client posted to Avvo
Happy with the Service

I was coming back home (Canada) when I got pulled over for doing 81 in 65 zone. I had no clue as in what to do. If I would've just simply paid the fine I would've lost 3 points in Canada on my license. So I googled lawyer and Seth's name came up. Contacted him and he advised me how he will pursue this ticket and what would be the likely outcome of it. What he said come out to be exactly that. VERY HAPPY WITH THE RESULT. I WILL RECOMMEND HIM.

Varun posted to Avvo