Seth Azria Logo

NY Traffic Ticket Defense Articles

Legal insights, guides, and tips for handling traffic tickets in New York.

Speeding Tickets 3 min read

The Speeding Charge That Does Not Depend on MPH

By Seth M. Azria, Esq.

Receiving a speeding ticket that does not reference a particular speed, while confusing to many, is entirely possible in New York. The basis for this ticket is New York Vehicle and Traffic Law (VTL) §1180(a).

VTL §1180(a) states in relevant part:

“No person may drive a vehicle at a speed greater than is reasonable and prudent under the conditions and having regard to the actual and potential hazards then existing.”

1. You Do Not Need to Be Over the Posted Limit

There is no requirement that the police officer allege a specific speed in miles per hour (MPH), only that your speed was not “reasonable or prudent under the conditions...then existing.” Here are two common scenarios where drivers receive this charge despite driving below the posted speed limit:

  • Weather-Related Accidents: While driving in bad weather (such as snow or heavy rain), a vehicle slips off the road. The police arrive at the scene and issue the driver a speeding ticket under §1180(a), assuming that if they slid, they were going too fast for the wet or icy conditions. (See People v. Miller, 57 AD3d 568 (2nd Dept. 2008)).
  • Hazardous Road Conditions: A road crowded by pedestrians or narrowed by parked cars creates a set of circumstances where even a speed lower than the posted limit may be charged as speeding that is not reasonable and prudent. (See St. Andrews v. O’Brien, 45 AD3d 1024 (3rd Dept. 2008)).
Penalties for §1180(a):
Want to know exactly what this charge could cost you in points and fines? Check out our detailed breakdown on Fines and Points for §1180(a).
Don't Mail in a Guilty Plea

Like all other traffic tickets, we strongly recommend against blindly mailing in a guilty plea to the court. The impact of this ticket on your finances and your ability to drive can often be reduced by pleading not guilty and negotiating with the prosecutor. We have negotiated thousands of tickets and welcome your call.

Call for a Free Consultation Contact Us Online
Worth it

Got pulled over for doing 16 miles over the speed limit on my way to Canada. Contacted his law firm and they reduced my ticket to what normally is 4 pts to 0 pts. Paid the fine and retained a clean driving record. Thank you Seth!

anonymous posted to Avvo
Great Results

I had received a speeding ticket a few months ago that would have been 5 points 20 MPH over the speed limit. I had not had a speeding ticket in a very long time and I was hesitant when looking for a lawyer but I saw good reviews about Seth Azria and decided to email him with my information. I received a response within a few hours and his charges were much lower than I was expecting to pay from what I had paid in the past. His staff was very friendly and I was kept well informed as to what was going on. He was able to get it reduced to no points and a very small fine. I was very happy with the results and would recommend him to anyone looking for help with speeding ticket.

John posted to Avvo
Google Review

I emailed Seth at first with some questions about a legal matter, and honestly wasn't sure what to expect. Instead of trying to sign me up as a client, he got on the phone with me and was straightforward, telling me I didn't actually need a lawyer for my situation, then pointed me toward the right resources. That kind of honesty says a lot about his character. I didn't end up needing to retain him for this particular case, but if I ever run into a legal issue in upstate New York, especially anything traffic related, Seth's the guy I'm calling. Appreciate the integrity.

Google Review

Very nice guy helpful