Card image

Complimentary Traffic Ticket Case Evaluations. Call Now. (315) 364-1155

Traffic Ticket Articles

Increased DWI Chemical Test Refusals and Implied Consent in New York

by Seth Azria on 7/06/2015

More New York Drivers are Refusing the DWI Chemical Test  

Yet another interesting trend that I have observed developing, which I view as being very dangerous, is the fact that an increasing number of people stopped for DWI are refusing to take the chemical breath test at the police station. Indeed, in the last month I have had four or five clients who did not consent to the test, and all of them are regretting their decision.

There used to be reasons why an attorney might say to a client, “It would behoove you to not take the breath test”—i.e., if the client was going to be charged with a felony or if they had been in an accident, particularly if injuries were involved. In such cases, we would want to make the DA prove their case without the breath test result, because they could only charge the client with a common law offense without the .08 BAC result available to them.

These days, however, I think that it is a monumentally bad idea to not take the chemical breath test.

There are a few reasons for this. First and foremost is the fact that any driver found to have refused to take a chemical breath test faces both criminal and civil penalties. If a driver refuses to consent to a chemical breath test, that driver will be scheduled for a refusal hearing before a NYS DMV Administrative Law Judge. If, after the hearing, it is concluded that the driver refused to submit to a validly request for a breath sample, that driver will lose driving privileges for one year, regardless of what the disposition is with regard to the underlying DWI charges. Further, there is a $500 fine assessed for refusing a chemical test.

There are situations where the defendant’s DWI related charges are dismissed, or the driver is found not guilty after trial, yet they still will have no driving privileges for one year, solely based upon the refusal. It is important to note that a chemical test refusal also counts as a previous conviction under New York law for the purposes of penalty calculations. In other words, it is as if the refusal conviction was a conviction. That means if a driver has been found to have refused a chemical test and is then arrested for a new DWI, the refusal conviction will act as a prior alcohol related offense, thus placing the driver at risk of enhanced charges and penalties.

Implied Consent Law and the DWI Chemical Test

New York State has an implied consent law. When you signed the application and subsequent forms for your driver’s license, you consented to comply with a lawful request to take the chemical/breath tests—although many young people are who sign up for their license are so excited that they have no idea what they are signing up for. Simply stated, when you get a driver’s license in New York you have already said in effect, “I will take a chemical test should you ask;” and you need to understand that driving is a privilege and not a right, so it can be taken away.

Unfortunately, the law in this area is often misunderstood. In fact, in Central New York, where I practice, a prominent DWI law firm has been advertising heavily on the radio, and some of their past advertisements make it seem like it may be a good idea for a driver to refuse to submit to chemical testing in the wake of a DWI arrest. I have had three clients in the past few months that told me that they refused to take the test because of this ad. What they do not understand is that refusing to submit to chemical testing is completely unrelated to what happens to the underlying charges in their case; and that they are going to lose their license for one year simply for refusing testing unless they win the refusal hearing—and that is a very hard thing to do because the burden in these cases is simply a preponderance of the evidence; the case against you does not have to be proved beyond a reasonable doubt.

Article adapted from partner David C. Bruffett's chapter in "Inside the Minds: Strategies for Defending DWI Cases in New York, 2015 ed. published by Aspatore Books, A Thomson Reuters business. 

Need help with your ticket?

One speeding conviction may cause premiums to increase over $2,000 in three years. The Zebra. 

Don't plead guilty. Consult with Us.

Our experienced traffic defense lawyers are available to talk to you about your case.

Free Consultations. Call Now.
(315) 364-1155


 

Can't talk now?

Schedule a time for a lawyer to call you when it's convenient.

 Schedule a Call for Later

Azria & Bruffett PLLC BBB Business Review

Top Rated Award Winning Law Firm in Syracuse


Top Rated Award Winning Law Firm in Syracuse


Top Rated Law Firm, Syracuse NY

 
Hire your traffic lawyer online. Start Now
Do not hesitate to hire him!

Me and a friend got in legal trouble in a town about 4 hours away from where we live. The charge was very threatening, and we expected to be dealing with it for months with little hope that it would go in our favor. We ended up having all of the charges dropped in the first appearance within about 40 minutes. Words cannot describe how much weight has been lifted off of our shoulders at a very modest price. Forever grateful for spending the time to research and find this excellent lawyer!

So helpful and professional

Mr. Habib and his firm were so helpful and courteous while working on my case. He was very reassuring and any questions I had were answered quickly. This is a excellent firm to work with.

Lynette posted to Avvo
As advertized

They took over the case and took care of my ticket, I got a good reduction in points

anonymous posted to Avvo
Google Review

I recommend this law firm as they are very knowledgeable and professional dealing with the NY speeding traffic ticket I had been charged with. I am very pleased with the negotiations this firm had negotiated on behalf of me. Thank you!

Traffic Ticket Lawyers: Statewide

Azria & Bruffett has helped thousands of clients minimize the effect of their traffic tickets. We have experience in courts all over New York State which helps us handle your case effectively and efficiently.

We offer free traffic ticket consultations. In your consultation, you will learn the best way to handle your ticket,  even if that means you don't need to hire us. We will cover the possible outcomes, costs, and timing of your case. 

Many counties have recently adopted self service web-based systems to handle traffic tickets. In those counties, you do not need a lawyer because handling a ticket is merely data entry on a website. 

Before calling, please review this information on where we take cases. Thank you.  

Albany, Allegany, Broome, Cattaraugus, Cayuga, Chautauqua, Chemung, Chenango, Clinton, Columbia, Cortland, Delaware, Dutchess, Erie, Essex, Franklin, Fulton, Genesee, Greene, Hamilton, Herkimer, Jefferson, Lewis, Livingston, Madison, Monroe, Montgomery, Niagara, Oneida, Onondaga, Ontario, Orange, Orleans, Oswego, Otsego, Rensselaer, Saratoga, Schenectady, Schoharie, Schuyler, Seneca, St. Lawrence, Steuben, Sullivan, Tioga, Tompkins, Ulster, Warren, Washington, Wayne, Wyoming and Yates counties.